Wild foxgloves in flower on a hillside above Errwood Hall in the Goyt Valley, Derbyshire, under a clear summer sky
Wild foxgloves in flower on a hillside above Errwood Hall in the Goyt Valley, Derbyshire, under a clear summer sky
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Colin Park · CC BY-SA 2.0

Climate & Conservation · In depth: medicinal plants

Bark, bells and bitter leaves: the plants that gave us medicine

Willow bark became aspirin, a country foxglove became a heart drug and a slow-growing yew became a cancer medicine. The plants behind the pills, the gardens that grew them first, the frozen vault saving their seeds, and where to see them for yourself.

Every plant in this story is armed. Rooted to the spot, unable to run from a hungry caterpillar or a grazing goat, plants defend themselves with chemistry: bitter alkaloids, astringent tannins, resins and essential oils. Cambridge University Botanic Garden counts more than 20,000 terpenoids described so far, and that is just one family of weapons. For most of its history, medicine has been the art of borrowing them.

The borrowing is far from finished. In its State of the World’s Plants and Fungi report of 2020, the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew counted 25,791 plants documented as medicinal. Here are six that changed the history of medicine, the gardens that grew them first, the frozen vault saving their seeds, and the places where you can see them for yourself.

Our advice: Admire these plants in the gardens at the end of this story and leave the chemistry to the chemists. This is a history of science, not a medicine cabinet, and several of the plants are poisonous: Cambridge University Botanic Garden notes that the whole foxglove, root and seeds included, is toxic.

Willow: the bark behind the pill

The willow got there first. Its use against pain is mentioned in the Ebers Papyrus, an Egyptian text from around 1500 BC, Cambridge University Botanic Garden records. Germany’s patent office adds that Hippocrates described it as a medicine against fever and pain around 400 BC, and that Celtic and Germanic peoples cooked a broth from the bark.

In 1763 the old knowledge was tested and confirmed for the Royal Society in London, the first time it had been checked by modern science.

The active ingredient took longer to pin down. In 1828 Johann Andreas Buchner and Pierre-Joseph Leroux isolated salicin from willow bark, which the body turns into salicylic acid. The acid worked, but it was hard on the stomach.

The French chemist Charles Gerhardt made acetylsalicylic acid in an impure form in 1853; on 10 August 1897, in the laboratory of Bayer at Elberfeld, now part of Wuppertal, chemists produced it in the pure, stable form that became the medicine.

Who deserves the credit is still debated. Bayer, among others, names its chemist Felix Hoffmann. His colleague Arthur Eichengrün later claimed the leading role, first in a letter written from the Theresienstadt concentration camp, where the Nazis had sent him in 1944, and until his death in 1949 he insisted his authorship had been denied because of his Jewish ancestry.

Germany’s patent office now says aspirin was more likely the result of teamwork.

The name is a botanical in-joke. The A stands for acetyl, and “spirin” comes from Spiraea, the genus of shrubs that are an alternative source of salicylic acid, according to the Science History Institute. The trademark entered the register of the Imperial Patent Office in Berlin on 6 March 1899.

Nobody, the patent office notes, really understood how it worked until 1971, when John Robert Vane found that it blocks the body’s production of prostaglandins, work later recognised with a Nobel Prize.

White willows (Salix alba) in full leaf on the banks of the Isar in Munich
White willows (Salix alba) in full leaf on the banks of the Isar in Munich
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Burkhard Mücke · CC BY-SA 4.0

Foxglove: one plant in twenty

In 1775, the Linda Hall Library records, a Birmingham physician named William Withering heard of a country woman’s remedy said to work against dropsy, the swelling of the body that often comes with a failing heart. Her concoction contained 20 different herbs. Withering suspected that only one of them mattered: the foxglove, Digitalis purpurea.

He spent the next ten years testing it, dried, distilled and powdered, made from flowers, leaves or roots, and kept a careful record of every case, failures included. The result, An Account of the Foxglove, and Some of its Medical Uses, appeared in 1785.

Withering was a botanist too: his guide to the plants of Great Britain, published in 1776, was arranged by Linnaeus’s new system, and his former home, Edgbaston Hall, now carries a blue plaque and serves as a golf clubhouse.

A flowering spike of foxglove (Digitalis purpurea) in a woodland in Hesse, Germany
A flowering spike of foxglove (Digitalis purpurea) in a woodland in Hesse, Germany
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Norbert Nagel · CC BY-SA 3.0

The foxglove’s power is also its danger. Its active compound, digoxin, is a cardiac glycoside that acts on the force of the heart’s beat. The gap between a medical dose and a poisonous one is small, and the amount in a plant extract was hard to measure, which is why, Cambridge University Botanic Garden says, it is now used less often than other similar drugs.

The poison is no accident: it is the plant’s defence against anything that tries to eat it.

Cinchona: the fever tree

Cinchona, a tree native to South America, owes its name to a story that Cambridge University Botanic Garden calls probably false: that its bark cured the wife of the Count of Chinchón. True or not, the bark had long been used against fevers, malaria above all. In 1820 a French chemist, Pierre Joseph Pelletier, and a French pharmacist, Joseph Caventou, isolated the substance responsible, quinine.

Their original preparation is in the Science Museum Group’s collection in London.

Quinine’s reach went far beyond medicine. The same garden notes that it allowed Europeans to combat malaria and to colonise Africa, and that its bark stayed in use until more efficient drugs were synthesised in the 1940s. The bitterness that flavours tonic water is a defence against insects: caterpillars dislike the taste and leave the leaves alone.

Cambridge’s gardeners add a firm footnote: do not make your own tonic at home, because too much quinine brings on “cinchonism”.

Flowers and buds of the red cinchona tree (Cinchona pubescens), whose bark contains quinine
Flowers and buds of the red cinchona tree (Cinchona pubescens), whose bark contains quinine
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © C T Johansson · CC BY 3.0

Sweet wormwood: the answer in the old books

Quinine and its successors did not hold the line forever. By the late 1960s, the Nobel Assembly records, efforts to eradicate malaria had failed and the disease was on the rise. In China, Tu Youyou turned to traditional herbal medicine.

A large screen of herbal remedies in malaria-infected animals threw up one promising candidate, Artemisia annua, sweet wormwood, but the results were inconsistent, so she went back to the ancient literature for clues.

The clues led her to a way of purifying the active agent, artemisinin. In 2015 she shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine “for her discoveries concerning a novel therapy against Malaria”.

Cambridge University Botanic Garden adds a twist worthy of a thriller: the plant makes artemisinin to stunt the growth of its neighbours, and because resistant strains of the parasite have appeared, the drug is now used only together with other antimalarials.

The feathery stems and tiny flower heads of sweet wormwood (Artemisia annua), the source of artemisinin
The feathery stems and tiny flower heads of sweet wormwood (Artemisia annua), the source of artemisinin
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Krzysztof Ziarnek, Kenraiz · CC BY-SA 4.0

Madagascar periwinkle: the wrong question, the right answer

Some discoveries start with a mistake. Healers in places including India, the Philippines and South Africa long used infusions of Madagascar periwinkle leaves against diabetes, according to the John Innes Centre. In the 1950s two teams, one at the drug company Eli Lilly and one at the University of Western Ontario, tested extracts in the hope of a new diabetes drug. Blood sugar in their mice barely moved.

White blood cell counts, however, fell dramatically.

Since some cancers, leukaemia among them, involve a proliferation of white cells, the two teams joined forces. The result was two drugs, vinblastine and vincristine, approved by the US Food and Drug Administration in the 1960s. The plant makes more than 120 alkaloids, says Cambridge University Botanic Garden, and is stingy with the useful ones: the John Innes Centre puts it at about 500 kilograms of dried leaves for a single gram of vinblastine.

Pink flowers of the Madagascar periwinkle (Catharanthus roseus), the plant behind vinblastine and vincristine
Pink flowers of the Madagascar periwinkle (Catharanthus roseus), the plant behind vinblastine and vincristine
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Mickaël Schauli · CC BY-SA 4.0

The white or pink flower grown in gardens and homes across the world is native to Madagascar, and its story raises a question Cambridge University Botanic Garden puts plainly. Many plants that supply medicines grow in developing countries, and there is considerable international discussion about how the people who live there should share in the benefits. The Nagoya Protocol is the legal framework written to make that sharing fair and equitable.

Pacific yew: the tree that had to be spared

In 1962, on an excursion in Washington State, a US Department of Agriculture botanist, Arthur Barclay, collected bark and other samples from the Pacific yew. It was one of some 30,000 samples tested between 1960 and 1981 in a joint search by the National Cancer Institute and the USDA for possible cancer treatments in natural products.

Two years later Monroe Wall and Mansukh Wani found that the yew’s extracts were toxic to living cells, and isolated the most potent compound: paclitaxel, later sold as Taxol.

Then came the snag. The Pacific yew grows slowly, treatment needed a great deal of bark, and stripping the bark kills the tree; Cambridge University Botanic Garden cites an estimate of three mature trees for each patient. Its cousin came to the rescue. The European yew carries taxol throughout the plant, so clippings could be harvested without felling anything, and prunings from Cambridge’s own yews once went into the drug.

Today it is made from cell cultures in laboratories.

Red arils among the needles of a European yew (Taxus baccata), whose clippings once supplied taxol
Red arils among the needles of a European yew (Taxus baccata), whose clippings once supplied taxol
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Nefronus · CC BY-SA 4.0

The National Cancer Institute’s partnership with Bristol-Myers Squibb took a semisynthetic form into commercial production from 1991, and Taxol now sits on the World Health Organization’s Model List of Essential Medicines. Not bad for some bark collected on a field trip.

Gardens of physic

Long before laboratories, there were gardens. UNESCO credits Padua, in 1545, with the world’s first university botanical garden. It keeps its original plan, a circular plot symbolising the world inside a ring of water for the ocean, holds more than 6,000 species, and still works as a centre of research; UNESCO says it made a profound contribution to botany, medicine and pharmacy.

Britain followed with physic gardens. In Edinburgh, Sir Robert Sibbald co-founded one at Holyrood Abbey in 1670, according to the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh; it grew into today’s Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh. In London, the Worshipful Society of Apothecaries leased riverside land at Chelsea on 9 October 1673. Chelsea Physic Garden began an international seed exchange in 1682 that, the garden says, continues today.

The study of plants was dropped from the medical syllabus in 1895, and the public was first let in only in 1987.

Order beds of labelled plants at Chelsea Physic Garden, founded by the Apothecaries in 1673
Order beds of labelled plants at Chelsea Physic Garden, founded by the Apothecaries in 1673
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Daderot · CC0

Not every old idea survived the scientists. Under the Doctrine of Signatures, plants were matched to the parts of the body they resembled, so walnuts, which look like small brains, were used for headaches. Willow and foxglove were later shown to have a scientific basis; many signature remedies were not.

Cambridge’s own first botanic garden, set up in 1762, was a physic garden with its plants arranged by the part of the body they were meant to treat.

The tradition lives on. The Royal College of Physicians in Regent’s Park keeps a garden of almost 1,000 plants, all with links to medicine, labelled green for the plants behind pharmaceutical drugs and red for those connected with the heart. Edinburgh’s Royal College of Physicians has its own small physic garden in a courtyard on Queen Street, with a bed devoted to the plants in medicine today.

Saving the pharmacy

Now the sobering part. Kew’s 2020 report estimated that 39.4 per cent of plant species, two in five, are threatened with extinction, almost double its estimate of 2016, a jump it puts down to better methods of assessment. Of the 5,411 medicinal plants whose conservation status has been assessed, 723, or 13 per cent, are threatened.

One, Brugmansia sanguinea, is already listed as extinct in the wild by the International Union for Conservation of Nature.

Demand is part of the problem. In South Africa, where some 27 million people rely on traditional healthcare, Kew reports that the number of medicinal species traded fell from 700 in 1998 to 350 in 2013, a drop experts believe may reflect fewer plants left to sell. Collecting bulbs, bark and roots is especially destructive: the plant dies after harvesting in around 86 per cent of cases.

The insurance policy is underground in Sussex. Kew’s Millennium Seed Bank at Wakehurst holds more than 2.4 billion seeds of almost 40,000 species, which Kew describes as the most diverse genetic resource of wild plant species in the world. Seeds are dried, then frozen at minus 20°C, a method that keeps about 90 per cent of seed-bearing species alive for the long haul.

The vaulted roofs of Kew’s Millennium Seed Bank at Wakehurst, West Sussex, on a summer day
The vaulted roofs of Kew’s Millennium Seed Bank at Wakehurst, West Sussex, on a summer day
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Diliff · CC BY-SA 3.0

The rest are the next puzzle. Around one species in ten has “recalcitrant” seeds that will not survive drying, Kew says, and in moist tropical forests more than half of tree and shrub species may have them; its scientists are scoping a large cryogenic store, the Kew Cryosphere. Cambridge University Botanic Garden calls the plant kingdom a natural library of potentially useful drugs.

The point of a seed bank is that nobody yet knows which volume holds the next aspirin.

Where to see them

You can meet most of this cast in a weekend. Chelsea Physic Garden grows medicinal and useful plants in its four walled acres by the Thames. Kew is a short trip from central London, and its wild garden, Wakehurst, home of the Millennium Seed Bank, sits in the Sussex Weald. Cambridge University Botanic Garden’s Medicines from Plants trail puts willow, foxglove, the fever tree, sweet wormwood, the periwinkle and the European yew on a single walk.

Further afield, the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh carries the physic garden of 1670 into its fourth century, and Kirstenbosch, on the slopes of Table Mountain in Cape Town, grows the Cape’s own plants. Opening days and times change with the seasons, so check each garden’s website before you go.

Films

On film

  1. The Millennium Seed Bank at WakehurstVideo © Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew
  2. 20 years of the Millennium Seed BankVideo © Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew
  3. Kirstenbosch National Botanical GardenVideo © South African National Biodiversity Institute

Films play from YouTube, which may set its own cookies once one starts.

Kew counts 25,791 plants documented as medicinal. Of the 5,411 assessed so far, 723 are threatened with extinction.

Sources
  1. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew: State of the World’s Plants and Fungi 2020 (press release)
  2. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew: the Seed Collection at the Millennium Seed Bank
  3. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: Medicines from Plants trail
  4. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: golden willow
  5. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: foxglove
  6. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: fever tree
  7. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: sweet wormwood
  8. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: Madagascar periwinkle
  9. Cambridge University Botanic Garden: European yew
  10. German Patent and Trademark Office: Aspirin
  11. Science History Institute: Felix Hoffmann
  12. Linda Hall Library: William Withering
  13. The James Lind Library: Withering W (1785)
  14. Science Museum Group Collection: original preparation of quinine by Pelletier and Caventou
  15. The Nobel Prize: Physiology or Medicine 2015, press release
  16. The Nobel Prize: Tu Youyou, facts
  17. John Innes Centre: vinblastine and vincristine, life-saving drugs from a periwinkle
  18. National Cancer Institute: a story of discovery, Taxol
  19. UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Botanical Garden (Orto Botanico), Padua
  20. Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh: the College Physic Garden
  21. Chelsea Physic Garden: history
  22. Royal College of Physicians: the Garden of Medicinal Plants